C.D. Warner, et al., comp. The Library of the World’s Best Literature.
An Anthology in Thirty Volumes. 1917.
Critical and Biographical Introduction
By Toru Dutt (1856–1877)
I
After four years’ travel in Europe the Dutts returned to India to resume their student life, and Toru began to learn Sanskrit. She showed great aptitude for the French language and a strong liking for the French character, and she made a special study of French romantic poetry. Her essays on Leconte de Lisle and Joséphin Soulary, and a series of English translations of poetry, were the fruit of her labor. The translations, including specimens from Béranger, Théophile Gautier, François Coppée, Sully-Prud’homme, and other popular writers, were collected in 1876 under the title ‘A Sheaf Gleaned in French Fields.’ A few copies found their way into Europe, and both French and English reviewers recognized the value of the harvest of this clear-sighted gleaner. One critic called these poems, in which Toru so faithfully reproduced the spirit of one alien tongue in the forms of another, transmutations rather than translations.
But marvelous as is the mastery shown over the subtleties of thought and the difficulties of translation, the achievement remains that of acquirement rather than of inspiration. But Toru’s English renditions of the native Indian legends, called ‘Ancient Ballads of Hindustan,’ give a sense of great original power. Selected from much completed work left unpublished at her too early death, these poems are revelations of the Eastern religious thought, which loves to clothe itself in such forms of mystical beauty as haunt the memory and charm the fancy. But in these translations it is touched by the spirit of the new faith which Toru had adopted. The poems remain, however, essentially Indian. The glimpses of lovely landscape, the shining temples, the greening gloom of the jungle, the pink flush of the dreamy atmosphere, are all of the East, as is the philosophic calm that breathes through the verses. The most beautiful of the ballads is perhaps that of ‘Savitri,’ the king’s daughter who by love wins back her husband after he has passed the gates of death. Another, ‘Sindher,’ re-tells the old story of that king whose great power is unavailing to avert the penalty which follows the breaking of the Vedic law, even though it was broken in ignorance. Still another, ‘Prehlad,’ reveals that insight into things spiritual which characterizes the true seer or “called of God.” Two charming legends, ‘Jogadhya Uma,’ and ‘Buttoo,’ full of the pastoral simplicity of the early Aryan life, and a few miscellaneous poems, complete this volume upon which Toru’s fame will rest.
A posthumous novel written in French makes up the sum of her contribution to letters. ‘Le Journal de Mlle. D’Arvers’ was found completed among her posthumous papers. It is a romance of modern French life, whose motive is the love of two brothers for the same girl. The tragic element dominates the story, and the author has managed the details with extraordinary ease without sacrificing either dignity or dramatic effect. The story was edited by Mademoiselle Bader, a correspondent of Toru, and her sole acquaintance among European authors. In 1878, the year after the poet’s death, appeared a second edition of ‘A Sheaf Gleaned in French Fields’ containing forty-three additional poems, with a brief biographical sketch written by her father. The many translators of the ‘Sakoontala’ and of other Indian dramas show how difficult it is for the Western mind to express the indefinable spirituality of temper that fills ancient Hindu poetry. This remarkable quality Toru wove unconsciously into her English verse, making it seem not exotic but complementary, an echo of that far-off age when the genius of the two races was one.