The Cambridge History of English and American Literature in 18 Volumes (1907–21).
Volume VI. The Drama to 1642, Part Two.
§ 17. Randolphs Amyntas
The third and last pastoral on our list does not require so full a consideration as the first two. It is not a poem like Fletcher’s, nor unfinished like Jonson’s; but it belongs to a new order of art, which has not the full humanity or high imagination of the Elizabethan era. Randolph does not attempt, like Fletcher and Jonson, to cast the pastoral into a new mould. His Amyntas or the Impossible Dowry follows the conventions of Tasso and Guarini, and its plot is deliberately artificial, removed from any contact with life’s realities. His style recalls the work of John Day, and has a scholarly finish and point that raise the play above the other pastorals of Jacobean times. It is in curious contrast to The Muses Looking-Glasse. In that play, the force of the writing, and a touch of dramatic reality in the sketch of the puritan onlookers, are remarkable. In Amyntas, Randolph’s muse is strangely subdued and gentle. He develops a very individual type of pathetic and ironical fantasy in his delineation of the mad Amyntas, which seems very far removed from the boisterous fun and rollicking rimes of Aristippus. This mellowing and softening of Randolph’s spirit extends to the comic scenes of the play, and gives us the Latin rimes of the orchard-robbing elves—the